Village News

Christmas Lights

241216 | A tale of two car parking strategies: spot the difference between Cornwall and Devon

A tale of two car parking strategies: spot the difference between Cornwall and Devon

Posted By Julia Penhaligon on 16th December 2024

By Julia Penhaligon

While Cornwall Council plans to clobber its own local residents by privatising car park management to an aggressive enforcement company in Birmingham, a council in Devon is taking a diametrically opposite approach.

Cornwall’s strategy has already caused alarm because of the prospect that motorists will be fined £100 if they are just one minute late returning to their vehicles.

Both councils are keen to generate more income from car parking.  Both councils started their formal “public consultations” on Thursday last week.

But the two councils are asking totally different questions.

Conservative-controlled Cornwall has launched another of its online consultations giving people until 9th January to comment.

Meanwhile the Liberal Democrat-controlled South Hams district council has given people until 5th January to say if they would welcome a “residents’ discount scheme.”

Such a scheme would load more of the financial burden of car park maintenance and administration on to tourists.

For example, at the moment it costs motorists £6.50 to park for a full day at Salcombe Creek.  But with the proposed increase, it would cost visitors £10 and locals £8.

South Hams council embraced the principle of “differential car parking charges” in November and aims to implement the scheme next month.

The South Hams approach has triggered protests from the district’s tourism lobby but appears to have been welcomed by local residents.

Car parking enforcement across Devon is mostly carried out by the county council.  Many car parks in Devon are owned by local town councils.

Cornwall Cornwall says it needs to privatise enforcement because it is too difficult and expensive for County Hall to manage.


 

The Cornwall Council (Off Street Parking Places) Order 2025 

Consultation Summary


Cornwall Council is inviting Comments on its proposed amendments- including the revocation of a number of car parks- from its Off-Street Parking Places Order, which governs the operation of its car parks.

Background:

Cornwall Council manages 132 chargeable car parks and a further 72 free car parks throughout Cornwall- the largest number of car parks spaces managed by a local authority in the UK. The revenue generated from the fees charges are invested back into maintaining the car parks , associated infrastructure and our highway and transportation network. This consultation proposes to remove a number of these car parks from the order to be leased and operated as a Car Park by a third party organisation.

Scheme Objectives




The proposed order will replace the current order and will propose to make the following amendments

A number of car parks will be removed from the Councils control

There will be an reduction to the maximum stay period in Old Bridge Street,Truro

Reserved Permit parking will be added to Tolcarne Road, Newquay

Amendments will be made to the minimum spend for JustPark Wallet

 

EngageSpace - To participate please register or login
via https://www.engagespace.co.uk/cornwall/consultation_Dtl.aspx?consult_Id=2358&status=2&criteria=I
Original reporting via https://cornwallreports.co.uk/a-tale-of-two-car-parking-strategies-spot-...

Book page

TitleCreated
2026-EXTENDED-17th April 2026 to 22nd April- Resurfacing Steamers Hill; Hatchs Hill; Angarrack Lane | 1 Apr 07:30 - 17 Apr 23:59 2 days 6 hours agoBook page
2026-April-POSTPONED-planned improvements i.e. install footpath, paint double yellow lines junction Grist Lane Hatchs Hill 5 days 19 hours agoBook page
2026 - Resurfacing Steamers Hill; Hatchs Hill; Angarrack Lane | 1 Apr 07:30 - 17 Apr 23:59 2 weeks 3 days agoBook page
250330; Closure order:30 Mar-17 Apr 2026; 07:30-17:00; Clearway Parking Zone; Hatchs Hill, Steamers Hill and Angarrack Lane 3 weeks 5 days agoBook page
Traffic/Roads - Marsh/Grist Lane - Traffic counts 2019 onwards 15 weeks 2 days agoBook page
Approved with conditions | PA25/07094 | First floor extension over existing garage to create Art studio with guest bedroom... 19 weeks 5 days agoBook page
PA25/07094 | First floor extension over existing garage to create Art studio with guest bedroom, covered parking area below | As 20 weeks 4 days agoBook page
251027 | 20mph Monitoring—Hayle & St Ives Speed Data; Phase 3a-May-Jun 24 v Sep-Oct 24; Steamers Hill; Gwinear;Carbis;Nancledra 24 weeks 4 days agoBook page
PA25/07184 | Retention of 4no. existing holiday pods, swimming pool, incidental building, extended driveway and annexe converted 25 weeks 14 hours agoBook page
251009 | Stark reality of life in Cornwall revealed through 2025 Vital Signs Report 27 weeks 1 day agoBook page
251010 | Cornwall backs 20mph rollout; St Austell's the only town to reject the plans 27 weeks 1 day agoBook page
250930 | Cornwall’s 20 mph speed limits have made the roads much safer 28 weeks 4 days agoBook page